Twosided markets with multihoming and exclusive dealing mark armstrong. This article studies incentives for a premium provider superstar to offer exclusive contracts to competing platforms mediating the interactions between consumers and firms. Jan 25, 2005 we provide a framework for analyzing two sided markets that allows for different degrees of product differentiation on each side of the market. They allow consumers to search, buy and install apps for their smartphone. Under multisidedness, platforms must choose a price structure and not only a price level for their service. Competition in twosided markets mark armstrong department of economics university college london august 2002. In professional team sports, leagues function as a platform that enables sponsors to interact with fans. A regulator failing to understand the nature of twosided markets might misleadingly complain about predation. Twosided markets, competitive bottlenecks and exclusive contracts 355 stop subscribing to the rival platform. Twosided markets, competitive bottlenecks and exclusive. With exclusive contracts, however, a plat form can set arbitrarily high non exclusive prices so that sellers never choose to multihome regardless of the rival platforms offer and then offer a. Twosided markets, competition and exclusionary practices. Network effects are captured within a vertical differentiation framework.
Interchange fees and incentives to invest in the quality of a. The diverting economic implications of onesided and twosided market forms can particularly be seen regarding the profitmaximizing price setting. Review of current literature and research directions. Their combined citations are counted only for the first article. Strategies for network platform evolution semantic scholar. Two sided markets, competitive bottlenecks and exclusive. To overcome the methodological challenge of selecting an appropriate equilibrium, this paper shows that many twosided market models are weighted potential games, and thus potential maximization, a refinement of nash equilibrium justified by many theoretical and experimental studies, can always select a unique.
Regulating overthetop service providers in twosided. Due to its special network externalities and the huge impact on traditional markets, two sided markets have aroused great concern of academics to the two sided market theory. With exclusive contracts, however, a plat form can set arbitrarily high non exclusive prices so that sellers never choose to multihome regardless of the rival platforms offer and then offer a slight price cut. This paper develops a model of a professional sports league with network externalities by integrating the theory of twosided markets into a contest model. Twosided markets, competitive bottlenecks and exclusive contracts, 32 e con. Thus we paved the way for microbased further advanced studies that will investigate turkish credit card market as a two sided market approach in detail. To overcome the methodological challenge of selecting an appropriate equilibrium, this paper shows that many two sided market models are weighted potential games, and thus potential maximization, a refinement of nash equilibrium justified by many theoretical and experimental studies, can always select a unique. Regulators should refrain from mechanically applying standard antitrust ideas where they do not belong. Antitrust policy for twosided markets by erik hovenkamp. Also, success of one side is closely interlinked to the success of the other side. Mobile platforms combine stateoftheart mobile phones, i. Nov 07, 2006 two sided markets, competitive bottlenecks and exclusive contracts by mark armstrong and julian wright. Twosided markets and price competition with multihoming.
The greater complexity of twosided markets tends to complicate market definitions and increases the amount of information required by policy makers. Exclusionary pricing in twosided markets sciencedirect. Theory 353, 37374 2007 demonstrating that exclusivity requirements can have complex competitive effects. All markets would at first sight appear to have two sides, namely buyers and sellers. Iain murray is vice president for strategy at the competitive enterprise institute cei. Twosided markets are composed of platform owners and two distinct user networks that either buy or sell applications for the platform.
These apps are built for a specific operating system and provide additional functionality. Strong network effects typically lead to multiple equilibria in two sided markets. Twosided markets, competitive bottlenecks and exclusive contracts article in economic theory 322. Competition in twosided markets article pdf available in the rand journal of economics 373. Each side of the market cares positively about the number of people on the other side and perhaps they care negatively about the number of people on their own side. When platforms are viewed as homogenous by sellers but heterogeneous by buyers, we show that competitive bottlenecks arise endogenously. Table 1 provides a few illustrations1of the twosided markets and shows that platforms often treat one side as a prot center and the other as. Antitrust and competition in twosided markets journal of. Corporate strategy and competition in twosided markets.
Lee this paper measures the impact of vertically integrated and exclusive software on industry structure and welfare in the sixthgeneration of the us video game industry 20002005. Functioning and key characteristics of twosided markets are described in this bachelor thesis by presenting three models of initial settings of twosided markets provided. Platform economy bibliography competitive enterprise. This paper presents theoretical models for three variants of such markets. Why political and economic freedom need each other. Based on the initial work of caillaud and jullien 2003, rochet and tirole 2003 and armstrong 2006, the literature has studied, among other problems, the role of the price structure in solving coordination problems. Finally, the role of exclusive contracts to prevent multihoming. The recognition that many markets are multisided leads to new and interesting positive and normative questions. Exploring the success factors of mobile business ecosystems. Two sided markets, competitive bottlenecks and exclusive contracts. Finally, the role of exclusive contracts to prevent multihoming is explored. This research attempts to implode various aspects of network. As used in antitrust, the term consumer appl ies to platform users even when they are them.
Additionally, further research should explicitly consider the dynamic effects of access regulation in two sided content markets, the possibility to establish a level playing field by deregulating traditional telcos and, in order to shed more light on debatable issues, conduct datadriven analyses, e. Two sided markets, competitive bottlenecks and exclu. Twosidedmarkets,competitivebottlenecksand exclusivecontracts markarmstrong. Monopoly platform in twosided markets with heterogeneous. Vertical integration and exclusivity in platform and twosided markets by robin s. Platform competition in two sided markets, lse research online documents on economics 24929, london school of economics and political science, lse library. Two sided markets, competitive bottlenecks and exclusive contracts created date. Sep, 2007 finally, the role of exclusive contracts to prevent multihoming is explored. In two sided markets, market definitions depend on prices charged to buyers and to sellers. The authors focus on multihomingthe choice of an agent in a user network to use more than one platform. Twosided markets, competitive bottlenecks, and exclusive contracts. The purpose of this paper is to start lling this gap.
Twosided markets, bank card payment networks, and public policy. Twosided markets, competitive bottlenecks and exclusive contracts created date. Injection withdrawal fees in electricity markets, telecom charges when caller and receiver side contract. It is sometimes the case that one side of the market is subsidized, and used to attract the other side from whom surplus can then be extracted. Optimal pricing decisions for the online video platform under. The term twosided market 2 may seem quite odd to the uninitiated. Request pdf twosided markets, competitive bottlenecks and exclusive contracts we provide a framework for analyzing twosided markets. Mazalov2,c, jie zheng3,d 1institute of economics, tsinghua university, beijing, china, 84 2institute of applied mathematical research, karelian research center, russian academy of sciences, 11, pushkinskaya street, petrozavodsk, russia 185910.
With exclusive contracts, however, a platform can set arbitrarily high nonexclusive prices so that sellers never choose to multihome regardless of the rival platforms offer and then offer a. They operate in a two sided market where agents are heterogeneous on both sides of the market and are allowed to multihome. App stores are a special kind of search and product market. Markets, where two, or more, groups of agents encounter via intermediary platform and there are network externalities between those groups, can be called twosided markets. The choice of a business model seems to be key to the success of a platform and receives much corporate attention.
When platforms are viewed as homogenous by sellers but heterogeneous by buyers, we show that competitive. When platform competition is intense, more consumers subscribe to theplatform hosting the superstar exclusively. In recent years, many scholars in the field of operations management also turn their attention to two sided platforms. In equilibrium, platforms do not compete directly for sellers, instead choosing to compete indirectly by. Competition among intermediation service providers. Pdf mobile platforms as twosided markets semantic scholar.
Despite this, it is sellers who choose to purchase from multiple platforms multihome. The ones marked may be different from the article in the profile. Optimal pricing decisions for the online video platform. Vertical integration and exclusivity in platform and two. The greater complexity of two sided markets tends to complicate market definitions and increases the amount of information required by policy makers. The authors focus on multihomingthe choice of an agent in a. Jan 20, 2010 many markets involve two groups of agents who interact via platforms, where one groups benefit from joining a platform depends on the size of the other group that joins the platform. Society for the advancement of economic theory saet, vol. Functioning and key characteristics of two sided markets are described in this bachelor thesis by presenting three models of initial settings of two sided markets provided by armstrong 2006. T heory 353, 37374 2007 demonstrating that exclusivity requirements can have complex competitive effects. Armstrong, mark and wright, julien 2007, twosided markets competitive bottlenecks and exclusive contracts, economic theory 32, 353380. Platform economy bibliography competitive enterprise institute.
Twosided markets, competitive bottlenecks and exclusive contracts. Twosided markets with multihoming and exclusive dealing. We provide a framework for analyzing twosided markets that allows for different degrees of product differentiation on each side of the market. Antitrust policy for twosided markets by erik hovenkamp ssrn. As used in antitrust, the term consumer applies to platform users even when they are. Many markets involve two groups of agents who interact via platforms, where one groups benefit from joining a platform depends on the size of the other group that joins the platform. A contest model of a professional sports league with two. Twosided markets, competitive bottlenecks, and exclusive. To address these issues, we present a model of competition in a twosided market. With exclusive contracts, however, a platform can set arbitrarily high nonexclusive prices so that sellers never choose to multihome regardless of the rival platforms offer and then offer a slight price cut. Sorry, we are unable to provide the full text but you may find it at the following locations. We show this competitive bottleneck equilibrium can be undermined when platforms have the ability to offer exclusive contracts to the seller side.
Caillaud and jullien 2003 and armstrong 2006 show that. Armstrong, mark and wright, julien 2007, two sided markets competitive bottlenecks and exclusive contracts, economic theory 32, 353380. Nma mergers in twosided markets 25 june 2010 5 introduction 1. Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda. In fact, the term twosided market refers to a specific type of market. To address these issues, we present a model of competition in a two sided market. Twosided markets ambrus, atilla and rosella argenziano.
Two sided markets, network externalities, exclusive contracts, competitive bottlenecks jel classification. Of course, as with all exclusive dealing theories this result depends on quite specific assumptions and ignores possible efficiencies from exclusive contracts. Managing a network platform business can be a complex preposition for the platform owner due to various intricacies that are associated with these platforms. Strong network effects typically lead to multiple equilibria in twosided markets. Platform market competition with endogenous side decisions. In twosided markets, market definitions depend on prices charged to buyers and to sellers. Linking turkish credit card market as twosided market. An empirical analysis of payment card usage by marc. Twosided markets are an area of considerable research in the field of industrial organisation. This cited by count includes citations to the following articles in scholar. Platform competition in two sided markets, fmg discussion papers dp409, financial markets group. Two sided markets, competitive bottlenecks and exclusive contracts, economic theory, springer.
These platforms have distinct users each having its own exclusive needs and requirements. Twosided markets and price competition with multihoming by. Under singlehoming there exists an interior equilibrium where networks exhibit asymmetric sizes and both firms enjoy positive profits. Despil this, it is sellers who choose to purchase from multiple platforms multihome. As technology and interconnectivity have continued to flourish, so too has an important and complex form of enterprise.
1227 979 97 1270 840 209 444 643 952 1273 1016 1039 499 480 1034 922 131 1097 1268 299 544 1366 600 1016 687 939 653 723 1061 23 1332 659 527 988 111 1057 1046 455 582 191 860 829 344 182 1224 1074